1. Updates provided as the World Health Assembly adopted its first drowning resolution in 2023 with current estimate of over 90% of drowning related deaths are preventable. Updated epidemiology provided.
2. Clarification on automated external defibrillator (AED) use provided. AEDs do have a limited role in the care of drowning patients; however, the application of these devices should not interfere with compressions and ventilation as shockable rhythms are present in less than 6% of patients.
3. Updated ER disposition recommendations based on grade of severity and mortality with associated flow chart (Figure 1). Grades 2 and below may be safely observed and likely discharged within 4-6 hours.
4. Expanded ICU management recommendations.
5. Recommendation for aggressive fever prevention (for neuroprotection) but no recommendation for traditional targeted temperature management in the post-cardiac arrest patient per the recent Targeted Temperature Management 2 trial.
6. Recommendations for the management of shivering.
7. No role for the routine use of prophylactic antibiotics.
8. Updated Swimming Induced Pulmonary Edema (SIPE).
9. Risk factors: Cold water, pre-existing (Cardiovascular) CV disease, overhydration, horizontal positioning during swimming, tight fitting wetsuits, and concurrent respiratory infections.
10. Diagnostic findings typical chest x-ray findings of perifissural and interstitial thickening, widened azygos vein diameter, and enlarged cardiac silhouette.
11. Management: ß2-agonists, Positive Pressure, Positive Expiratory Pressure (PEP) Device.
While various necessary military occupations put service members at increased risk for drowning, particularly those serving in the Navy and Marine Corps, this risk is mitigated through methodical training and operational risk management processes. However, drowning events in combat and operational environments can occur and are highly influenced by the tactical environment. In civilians, drowning is thought to be preventable in over 90% of cases.1-2 As a result of the significant human, social, and economic tolls of drowning, the World Health Assembly adopted their first resolution regarding drowning prevention in 2023.3 The purpose of this clinical practice guideline provides an overview of drowning and associated conditions based on the best available current medical evidence. It should be used as a standardized framework to guide first responders, prehospital emergency medical service personnel, and medical department personnel in evaluating, diagnosing, and managing common in-water emergencies. Caregivers supporting operations with an increased risk of drowning should review this CPG with the entire medical team including first responders.
MILITARY OCCUPATIONS WITH DROWNING RISK AND EPIDEMIOLOGY
Various military occupations involve significant water exposure and carry a risk of drowning. These include but are not limited to naval operations at sea, military special operations, combat swimmers, divers, and amphibious assault units. Each unit has risk management measures in place to mitigate the risk of drowning events and subsequently provide immediate aid.
Between 2013 and 2017, 359 recreational and line of duty drowning cases were identified amongst active-duty service members. Generally, members of the Marine Corps are at highest risk as well as members working within motor transport occupations. Off duty alcohol related incidents and alcohol use disorder continue to play a significant factor in drowning risk.2,4
Combat related drowning incidents have been associated with a mortality as high as 37.5% and are often related to vehicle roll overs. One 2-year epidemiology study found that combat related drowning represents 3% of all combat deaths.5-6
Man-overboard events aboard naval vessels at sea are uncommon occurrences but are associated with a high mortality when they occur. Between 1970 and 2020 there were 220 man-overboard events on U.S. Naval subsurface and surface vessels involving 352 casualties with an associated 72% mortality.7
Naval vessel collisions at sea impacting the integrity of the ship’s hull can result in highly lethal drowning events. The 2017 USS Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain collisions with separate large civilian commercial ships both resulted in significant hull breaches below the waterline. In the two events, there were 85 reported casualties from the combined warship crews, 20% (17) died from drowning.
The epidemiology of drowning incidents during amphibious vehicle training is unknown, but they do occur. In 2020 an Amphibious Assault Vehicle (AAV) carrying 15 Marines and 1 Sailor took on water and sunk during a training exercise. Ultimately 8 Marines and 1 Sailor died from drowning. One severely injured Marine required ongoing critical care and respiratory support.8
CIVILIAN EPIDEMIOLOGY OF DROWNING
Reported incidence of 360,000 to over 500,000 civilian deaths attributed to unintentional drowning annually, not including boating accidents or those related to natural disasters. *These numbers are thought to be underreported. 2, 9-10
Worldwide, children ages 1-4 have the highest rates of drowning, followed by children ages 5-9. Boys are twice as likely to die from drowning.3
It is the leading cause of death or contributing factor among scuba divers (100-150/year). Primary etiology of death can be difficult to determine as distinction between equipment malfunction or medical emergency can be challenging.10-12
Drowning occurs when water fills the airways for any reason. It is important to note that progressive aspiration of water can result in hypoxemia. If loss of consciousness occurs, the continued hypoxemia can result in bradycardia and cardiac arrest. In the lungs, aspiration can cause a washout and destruction of alveolar surfactant resulting in severe hypoxia, alveoli derecruitment, reduced pulmonary compliance and noncardiogenic pulmonary edema, all of which can complicate ventilator management. It should also be noted that there is no such thing as “Near Drowning.” Correct terminology includes “Non-Fatal Drowning” and “Fatal Drowning.”
Immersion in water when associated with panic, exhaustion, inadequate water competency, a medical emergency such as lethal cardiac dysrhythmia or seizure, or effects of hypo/hyperthermia can lead to drowning from one of the following mechanisms:10-15
In the civilian and military environment, one of the most important principles in drowning management is to first prevent drowning. Examples of prevention and operational risk management in high-risk military occupations include:
Patients requiring continued resuscitation or those with concern for hypothermia may require more advanced prehospital care which cannot be delivered by typical bystanders such as definitive airway management, supplemental oxygen or mechanical ventilatory support, gastric decompression, or thermal insulation.11,15 Aggressive resuscitation attempts should be initiated unless clear signs of death or as limited by operational requirements. Patients have survived prolonged submersion historically, especially in the hypothermic environment.13 For this level of care, use the typical ABCDE format below.
ENVIRONMENT (HYPOTHERMIA MANAGEMENT)
TERMINATING RESUSCITATION EFFORTS11,19
INITIAL ER ASSESSMENT AND INTERVENTIONS
Upon arrival to the Emergency Room (ER), rapidly evaluate the patient and rule out traumatic injury. Perform primary (ABCDE) and secondary assessment with specific focus on the following: secure airway, provide adequate oxygenation, ensure hemodynamic stability, gastric decompression, thermal insulation, and identifying concomitant traumatic injury. 10,11,19,22 Following initial ER resuscitation, specific systems-based interventions may be applied as noted in the ICU Management section. Additional immediate interventions below (does not substitute for ER standards of care):
Once the patient is stabilized from a respiratory and hemodynamic standpoint, disposition should be determined. Figure 1 below helps to establish guidelines for ICU admission versus observation and safe discharge based drowning mortality risk and drowning grade (Table 3).
Patients with a Grade 2 or lower may safely be observed either in the ER or non-intensive care inpatient observation for 4-6 hours.1
Patients with Grades 3-6 should be admitted to the ICU.1
Appropriate consults should be made at this time and may include critical care (medical and neurological), cardiology, psychology.
NEUROLOGIC
The majority of long term sequalae of drowning events are secondary to neurologic injury. Early efforts should be made to improve central nervous system oxygen delivery while providing evidence-based neuroprotection in the post-resuscitative period.
In patients who are still rewarming, aggressive shivering control should be implemented (See Figure 2 on right for an example of shivering management protocol). Significant adverse effects from prolonged shivering include lactic acidosis, elevated intracranial pressure, rhabdomyolysis, discomfort, and interference with monitoring devices.24
Aspiration of both seawater and freshwater in relatively small quantities can lead to disruptions in the surfactant equilibrium of the lungs. Reduced surfactant leads to atelectasis which can make patients more prone to atelectrauma and subsequent biotrauma (neutrophil migration and subsequent acute respiratory distress syndrome or sepsis).36,38 Osmotic shifts in the alveoli can lead to noncardiogenic pulmonary edema which results in reduced compliance, right to left shunting, and hypoxemia. Evidence-based care for mechanically ventilated patients should be followed. 2
Low output heart failure and lethal dysrhythmias are common in drowning victims. While hypoxemia is the primary driver of these conditions, correction of hypoxemia may not immediately restore normal cardiac function and ICU physicians should be prepared to manage these issues. Reduced cardiac output may lead to cardiogenic component of pulmonary edema or worsen additional organ failure (e.g., cardiorenal syndrome).1
HEMATOLOGIC, ENDOCRINE, AND RENAL
Drowning victims requiring the ICU are critically ill and can be prone to the same hematologic, metabolic, and renal pathologies as other ICU patients. There is no evidence that there is clinically significant hemolysis or electrolyte shifts in drowning patients. Rates of renal failure secondary to decreased perfusion during resuscitative efforts or subsequent decreased cardiac output are similar to other cardiac arrest patients.
There is no role for prophylactic antibiotics in drowning victims either in freshwater or saltwater. Furthermore, rates of antimicrobial resistance in bacteria obtained from seawater drowning victims is negligible and broad-spectrum coverage is not indicated.
Most commonly presents in individuals conducting sustained strenuous surface swimming in cold water (e.g., Marine combat swimmers, special operators, scuba divers, and triathletes).26,27 Studies have shown a variable incidence of SIPE among different populations. Symptom severity can range from full recovery within 24 hours to death.28-33 While severe outcomes are possible, most otherwise healthy individuals will recover within 24-48 hours. Recurrence of SIPE is not uncommon.34
RISK FACTORS
During or immediately after exertional water immersion/swimming:
Incompletely understood and thought to be due to:
POPULATION OF INTEREST
Drowning casualties
INTENT (EXPECTED OUTCOMES)
PERFORMANCE/ADHERENCE MEASURES
DATA SOURCE
SYSTEM REPORTING & FREQUENCY
RESPONSIBILITIES
It is expected that medical department personnel, particularly of the sea services (U.S. Navy, U.S. Marine Corps, U.S. Coast Guard, and U.S. Merchant Marine) will become familiar with these clinical practice guidelines and incorporate them into both operational planning and emergency medical response plans.
GENERAL PREVENTION
COLD WATER IMMERSION/SELF AID
RESCUE AND IN-WATER RESUSCITATION
**Please note this is placed as an appendix based on standard international recommendations. This does not take the place of standard unit military training.**
GOALS
References
Hyperbaric Support Point of Contact Information (non-emergency)
Generally, military diving operations that involve deploying to a distant site, require that a recompression chamber be identified beforehand and on standby in the event of a diving casualty. Frequently, diving units will transport a Transportable Recompression Chamber System or Standard Navy Double Lock Recompression Chamber System to the location of diving operations. However, occasionally, diving units are unable to transport these recompression chamber systems and must utilize a non-Navy certified chamber in proximity to diving operations. Military diving units should follow unit policies and procedures. Chapter 6 of the Navy Dive Manual includes information on determining the level of chamber needed for a given dive profile. Additional resources are listed below in the event that organic assets are not available in the event of a diving related emergency.
NAMI Hyperbaric Medicine – Department 53HY - Mon-Fri from 07:30AM to 4:00PM CST
Supervisor of Salvage and Diving, USN (Via NAVSEA and DAN)
Divers Alert Network (DAN)
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION DEFINITIONS 1,2
1. Immersion: “some portion of the body is covered in water” (i.e. head is out of the water).
2.Submersion: “during submersion, the entire body, including the airway, is under water” (i.e. head is in the water).
3.Submersion injuries: “water-related conditions that do not involve the airway and respiratory systems.
4. Drowning: “the process of experiencing respiratory impairment from submersion/immersion in liquid.” The drowning process begins with respiratory impairment as the person’s airway goes below the surface of the liquid (submersion) or water splashes over the face while being completely in a liquid (immersion).1-3 Subdivided into 3 categories:
5. Water rescue: “submersion or immersion incident without evidence of respiratory impairment.”1-4
6. Shallow water blackout: “hyperventilating to decrease hypercapnic drive to breathe and prolong ability to stay under water such that hypoxemia results in unconsciousness.” The compulsion to breathe from hypercapnia (acidosis) is physiologically more potent than hypoxemia (except when subverted by hyperventilation – e. lowering CO2).5
7. Asphyxia: “a condition where breathing stops and both hypoxia and hypercapnia occur simultaneously due to: (1) the absence of gas to breathe; (2) the airway being completely obstructed; (3) respiratory muscles being paralyzed; or (4) respiratory center failing to send impulses to ” Running out of compressed air is a common cause of asphyxia in SCUBA diving.1,5,6
8. Drowning after shallow water diving: Diving into shallow water makes concussion, head injury, and cervical spine (C-spine) injury more common, so rescuer must balance C-spine precautions against time of extraction (normally in drowning C-spine precautions are not required because the risk is < 0.5%). Also consider drug/alcohol impairment.1,69.
9. Warm water drowning: Unplanned submersion → panic and violent struggle → gulping / swallowing of air and water → breath holding until hypoxia leads to unconsciousness → gag reflex relaxing resulting in passive influx of water → drowning if PFD does not keep airway out of the water.1
10. Cold water drowning: Impacts every organ system similar to complex trauma. Sudden immersion in cold water ( < 91.4°F/33 °C) causes panic, reflexive gasp for air and rapid breathing making:1-5, 8-10
TERMS NOT TO USE
Terms NOT to use as they do not have diagnostic or therapeutic distinctions (although still widely used by medical professionals and the lay public, so important to be familiar with them).1,4,5,7,8,11
1. Wet drowning: “Fluid is aspirated into the lungs.” Aspiration of water occurs in only 80-90% of cases and does not change the treatment or management.
2. Dry drowning: “Fluid is not aspirated; death is due to laryngospasm and glottis closure.” Asphyxia still occurs secondary to laryngospasm occurring in 10-20% of cases, but no change in management. Difference is only relevant at autopsy.
3. Secondary drowning/Delayed onset of respiratory distress: Varied definitions with death occurring from 1-72 hours after initial resuscitation due to acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Fifteen percent of victims conscious at initial resuscitation subsequently die from ARDS.
4. Near drowning: “Suffocation by submersion in a liquid with at least temporary survival. Death from near drowning occurs after 24 hours.” Caused confusion because it had 20 different published definitions, most commonly if the person is rescued at any time, thus interrupting the process of drowning.
5. Immersion syndrome: “Sudden death immediately following submersion in very cold water” thought to be caused by vagal nerve stimulation resulting in overwhelming bradycardia.
6. Active drowning: Witnessed drowning.
7. Passive drowning: Unwitnessed drowning.
8. Fresh water vs. saltwater drowning: Typical human aspiration during drowning is 4 mL/kg. To change blood volume requires 8mL/kg, or to alter electrolytes require 22 mL/kg. Therefore, not clinically significant, and instead focus remains on hypoxemia, acidosis, and pulmonary injury rather than electrolyte or volume status.
REFERENCES
Airway Management Supplies
Ventilation and Oxygenation Supplies
IV/IO Access and Fluid Resuscitation Supplies
Circulation and Hemodynamics Support/Monitoring
Temperature Management
Medication Administration Supplies
Personal Protective Equipment
Documentation Supplies
For additional information including National Stock Number (NSN), refer to Logistics Plans & Readiness (sharepoint-mil.us)
DISCLAIMER: This is not an exhaustive list. These are items identified to be important for the care of combat casualties.
The purpose of this Appendix is to ensure an understanding of DoD policy and practice regarding inclusion in CPGs of “off-label” uses of U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved products. This applies to off-label uses with patients who are armed forces members.
Unapproved (i.e. “off-label”) uses of FDA-approved products are extremely common in American medicine and are usually not subject to any special regulations. However, under Federal law, in some circumstances, unapproved uses of approved drugs are subject to FDA regulations governing “investigational new drugs.” These circumstances include such uses as part of clinical trials, and in the military context, command required, unapproved uses. Some command requested unapproved uses may also be subject to special regulations.
Additional Information Regarding Off-Label Uses in CPGs
The inclusion in CPGs of off-label uses is not a clinical trial, nor is it a command request or requirement. Further, it does not imply that the Military Health System requires that use by DoD health care practitioners or considers it to be the “standard of care.” Rather, the inclusion in CPGs of off-label uses is to inform the clinical judgment of the responsible health care practitioner by providing information regarding potential risks and benefits of treatment alternatives. The decision is for the clinical judgment of the responsible health care practitioner within the practitioner-patient relationship.
Consistent with this purpose, CPG discussions of off-label uses specifically state that they are uses not approved by the FDA. Further, such discussions are balanced in the presentation of appropriate clinical study data, including any such data that suggest caution in the use of the product and specifically including any FDA-issued warnings.
With respect to such off-label uses, DoD procedure is to maintain a regular system of quality assurance monitoring of outcomes and known potential adverse events. For this reason, the importance of accurate clinical records is underscored.
Good clinical practice includes the provision of appropriate information to patients. Each CPG discussing an unusual off-label use will address the issue of information to patients. When practicable, consideration will be given to including in an appendix an appropriate information sheet for distribution to patients, whether before or after use of the product. Information to patients should address in plain language: a) that the use is not approved by the FDA; b) the reasons why a DoD health care practitioner would decide to use the product for this purpose; and c) the potential risks associated with such use.